A Systematic Withdrawal Plan is the reverse of a SIP. Instead of putting money in every month, you take a fixed amount out of a mutual fund every month, while the rest stays invested and keeps earning. Retirees use it as a pension substitute; others use it to fund a child’s hostel fees or to supplement a lower income during a career break.
The question an SWP calculator answers is simple but important: will the money last?
A worked example
Say you retire with a corpus of ₹10 lakh in a conservative hybrid fund that you expect to return 8% a year, and you want to withdraw ₹10,000 per month for 10 years.
-
Total withdrawn over 10 years: ₹12,00,000
-
Balance left at the end: ₹3,90,180
In other words, you put in more than you withdrew, but you still end up with close to ₹4 lakh. That’s because the money kept earning 8% the entire time.
Now look at the sensitivity:
Similarly, increasing the amount to ₹15,000 a month for 20 years means your money will last for only 7 years and 5 months. If you increase the amount to ₹12,000 a month for 10 years, you would be left with nothing to draw. The difference between a good and a bad plan is only a few thousand rupees a month.
How the calculator works
Each month, it does two things, in sequence:
- The balance then increases by one month of return (yearly rate/12).
- Your withdrawal is subtracted.
If at any point during the period the fund balance hits zero, then the account terminates, and the profile of how long the money lasted is shown. This is how a real SWP would behave; the managers would sell off a small proportion of the units each month to pay you.
The 4% idea, and why it matters
Financial advisors refer to a number they call a “safe withdrawal rate.” That is, a withdrawal rate of about 4% of the initial corpus, adjusted for inflation in subsequent years, has been shown to leave enough for a 30-year retirement. At₹50L this would be₹ 2L/year or close to₹ 16,700/month.
Indian inflation is usually above the set rule (it was higher for all the countries in which the rule was tested), so most planners recommend gravitating more towards 3-5% here. Check your own numbers in the calculator: If you’re very close to going out of funds at the end of your target time frame, your plan has no cushion for a rough year.
Things to think about before starting an SWP
-
Which fund? An SWP from a pure equity fund offers better long-run growth but may push you to sell units at a discount during a crash. Many retirees hold 2-3 years’ worth of withdrawals in a debt/ liquid fund and the rest in equity.
-
Exit loads. Certain funds impose a 1% exit charge if you sell the units within a year. You can avoid this fee by beginning the SWP after this period.
-
Tax. The gains component of all partial withdrawals is taxed at the time of withdrawal. This aspect generally makes SWP a more tax-friendly investment than interest on FD for individuals in higher tax brackets.
-
Inflation. A ₹30,000-a-month requirement today will be close to ₹54,000 in 10 years if inflation is at 6%. A flat SWP would feel psychologically shrinking.
SWP or dividend (IDCW) option?
They go for the dividend route, now called IDCW (Income Distribution cum Capital Withdrawal), to get a steady income. However, here’s the hitch: IDCW payouts are neither fixed nor guaranteed. The fund house decides the amount and timing of payouts, and 100% of the payout is treated as income and taxed at your slab rate.
An SWP from the growth plan gives flexibility in amount and timing; the only thing is that you are taxed only on the gain component of each withdrawal. For someone who wants a regular monthly income from mutual funds, the SWP is the most flexible and tax-efficient product. IDCW may be the right option for someone who doesn’t mind irregular payments and wants to stay in a lower tax bracket.
Practice problem
Corpus of ₹25 lakh at 7% p.a.: How much can I withdraw per month for 20 years and still have about nothing left? Play around with the numbers in the calculator: withdrawing about ₹19,380 per month depletes your corpus in roughly 20 years. A monthly withdrawal of ₹15,000 still leaves something after 20 years-a little extra padding if returns turn out to be lower.
Using the result
Run three cases: your case, and then two additional cases-one slightly less aggressive, one slightly less conservative (such as 6% vs. 8%). If your plan survives the more aggressive case, then you know you’ve covered your bases; if it doesn’t, start smaller and increase it after a few good years.
Speaking of the first question, just run the retirement calculator to understand the corpus that you require. If you are looking to build that corpus with a monthly investment, then the SIP calculator is the one to go for.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good SWP withdrawal rate?
So in your base case, you wouldn't withdraw more than 4-6% annually if you were counting on that corpus to last 20-30 years. The higher those returns are, the faster those withdrawals will deplete the principal.
How is SWP taxed?
Know that every withdrawal is treated as a sale of units, and only the gain portion of each sale is taxed. Gains on Equity funds held for 1 year or more than ₹1.25 lakh p.a. are taxed at 12.5%. Gains on debt funds are taxed based on your slab rate.
Does this calculator account for inflation?
No. It assumes the same withdrawal each month. If you need to bump your withdrawals (shrimp) down the road, you will want a pretty good cushion in the corpus.
Is SWP better than a monthly income FD?
SWP from a debt / hybrid fund could be tax-efficient, as you're taxed on the gain, not the full amount you get. But an FD will ensure regular income, while a debt fund may not.
This calculator gives estimates for planning and education. It is not financial, tax or professional advice; check important figures with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser. See our disclaimer.